What is an old fashioned?Whiskey, sugar and bitters — and ours at Fiena, King's Cross

A guest with a cocktail at the green marble bar at Fiena

Few cocktails are as simple, or as lasting, as the old fashioned. At Fiena, our family-run Italian cafe, bar and restaurant at 4 Medway Court, Judd Street, London WC1H 9QX, a few minutes' walk from King's Cross St Pancras, the Old fashioned is one of the classics on the cocktail list. Here's where it comes from.

In this story
  1. The original cocktail
  2. A myth, busted
  3. Our old fashioned at Fiena
  4. What to eat with it

The original cocktail

An old fashioned is made by muddling sugar with bitters and water, then adding whiskey, typically rye or bourbon. It's traditionally served over ice in a short "old fashioned" or rocks glass, and it's an official cocktail of the International Bartenders Association.

The recipe goes back to the early 1800s. In May 1806 a newspaper in Hudson, New York, gave the first documented definition of a "cocktail": spirits, bitters, water and sugar. As bartenders added liqueurs and more complicated recipes through the 19th century, some drinkers started asking for the simpler, earlier style, and the name "old-fashioned" was attached to it. The term dates to 1880, and the earliest known recipe by that name was published in Chicago in 1888. Background from Wikipedia's old fashioned page.

A myth, busted

The drink is often said to have been invented at the Pendennis Club in Louisville, Kentucky. Cocktail historians reject this: the Chicago Daily Tribune was already discussing "old fashioned cocktails" in 1880, and the club wasn't founded until 1881. Louisville still adopted it as its official cocktail in 2015.

A green banquette and a framed portrait on the wall at Fiena

Our old fashioned at Fiena

Ours is made with Buffalo Trace bourbon, Angostura bitters and gomme syrup, and all our cocktails use a 50ml spirit measure. If you like it, try the whiskey sour, also made with Buffalo Trace, or the bitter-sweet Negroni. For whisky by the measure, see our whisky and bourbon shelf.

What to eat with it

A stirred, whiskey-forward drink suits rich, savoury food. From the main menu, try the Lamb cutlets with beef jus, the Fiena burger with smashed beef patties and caramelised onions, or Saltimbocca alla Romana. To finish, the Tiramisu or warm Chocolate brownie. See the Fiena burger and saltimbocca.

Guests like a drink at the bar here. Kiley wrote: I’d also recommend sitting outside and enjoying a cocktail here. (Kiley, Google review) And Normof: Wine was good, too. (Normof, Google review)

Visit Fiena

Book a table on Judd Street.

Bourbon, bitters and sugar, the old way, on Judd Street. Book a table or just walk in. Please drink responsibly.

More from the journal

All stories

3 min read

What is rum?

Rum has one of the most colourful histories of any spirit, from Caribbean sugar plantations to the Royal Navy's daily ration. At Fiena, our family-run Italia...

Read the story